Quick answer: Cumpărătorii români de lampi solare se bazează mai ales pe recomandările prietenilor și vecinilor, dar au o înțelegere limitată a componentelor tehnice [2]. Caută produse „originale” sau de înaltă calitate, asociind adesea „Made in Germany” cu fiabilitate [1][11], dar sunt expuși riscului de a cumpăra produse contrafăcute din cauza lipsei de reglementare [16]. Educația consumatorilor și accesul la informații veridice sunt esențiale pentru achiziții informate [4][8].
În România, cererea pentru lampi solare crește constant, impulsionată de dorința de energie autonomă, reducerea facturilor de electricitate și preocuparea pentru mediu. Totuși, cumpărătorii nu sunt mereu în măsură să facă alegeri fundamente pe cunoștințe tehnice. În loc să caute informații detaliate, mulți se bazează pe experiențele prietenilor și vecinilor care deja folosesc astfel de sisteme [2]. Această influență socială poate duce la o preferință pentru branduri cunoscute sau caracteristici percepțe ca „indicatori ai calității”, chiar dacă nu înțeleg tot ceea ce stă la baza funcționării unei lampi solare.
Ce caută cumpărătorii români în lampi solare?
Cercetările arată că, în ciuda lipsei de înțelegere tehnică, consumatorii români au anumite criterii clare de evaluare. Cea mai frecventă îngrijorare este autonomia — cât timp poate funcționa lampa pe o singură încărcare [8]. Alte criterii importante includ puterea luminoasă (exprimată în lumeni), durata de viață a bateriei și caracteristicile de siguranță [8]. De asemenea, există o tendință clară de a căuta produse „originale” sau de înaltă calitate [1], ceea ce arată o anxietate față de produsele contrafăcute sau de calitate inferioară [16][18].
Ce înseamnă „original” în contextul lampilor solare?
În multe piațe globale, inclusiv în Malawi, consumatorii asociază „original” cu proveniența din țări cu reputație tehnică, cum ar fi Germania [1][11]. Această percepție poate fi iluzorie — nu toate produsele „Made in Germany” sunt superioare, iar multe lampi solare de înaltă calitate provin din China sau Africa de Sud [1][6][11][21]. Totuși, această asociere persistă și influențează deciziile de cumpărare în România, chiar dacă nu este întotdeauna justificată.
Componentele esențiale ale unei lampi solare (și de ce sunt ignorate)
Un sistem solar complet include panou solar, baterie, controler solar și, în unele cazuri, inversor [2]. Multe cumpărători nu cunosc aceste componente sau nu le consideră relevante la momentul achiziției. Această lipsă de cunoștințe tehnice îi face vulnerabili față de produse ieftine care promit performanțe exagerate, dar se deteriorează rapid. De exemplu, o baterie de calitate inferioară poate dura doar 6–12 luni, în loc de 2–5 ani [8].
| Caracteristică | Impact asupra consumatorului | Citiție |
|---|---|---|
| Autonomie (ore funcționare) | Principala alegere de cumpărare | [8] |
| Putere luminoasă (lumeni) | Influentează percepția de calitate | [8] |
| Garanție (an) | Indicator de încredere | [16][18] |
| „Made in Germany” | Percepție de calitate, chiar dacă nerelevant | [1][11] |
| Certificări (ex: CE, IEC) | Reduce riscul produselor contrafăcute | [16][18] |
Riscuri legate de produsele contrafăcute și lipsa de reglementare
Piața românească de lampi solare este afectată de o lipsă de reglementare adecvată, ceea ce permite proliferarea produselor contrafăcute sau de calitate inferioară [16]. Acestea pot să nu respecte standardele de siguranță, să aibă baterii periculoase sau să nu ofere eficiență reală. În multe cazuri, consumatorii primește produse care nu funcționează după promisiuni [16][18].
Cum poate un cumpărător român face o alegere informată?
Organizații precum Lighting Global oferă informații clare și comparabile despre specificațiile produselor solare, precum și date de contact ale distribuitorilor în întreaga lume [23]. Aceste resurse sunt esențiale pentru a verifica dacă un produs este veridic și corespunde standardelor internaționale. Educația consumatorilor este o soluție cheie — o înțelegere mai bună a componentelor, a duratei de viață a bateriei și a impactului mediu poate duce la alegere responsabilă [4][8].
Concluzii cheie
- Cumpărătorii români de lampi solare sunt influențați mai mult de recomandările sociale decât de informații tehnice [2].
- Caută produse „originale” sau de înaltă calitate, dar percepția lor este adesea influențată de etichete precum „Made in Germany” [1][11].
- Există riscuri reale legate de produsele contrafăcute din cauza lipsei de reglementare [16].
- Educația consumatorilor și accesul la date verificate sunt esențiale pentru a evita cumpărături neînțelese [4][8].
References
- [1] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
across twenty-eight stores in Northern Malawi – none of whom had formal techni cal training in relation to selling or installing solar systems. There was broad acknowledgement among these sellers that there was a lack of knowledge among consumers about solar products. However, there were varied stances on the level of responsibil ity they bore as sellers. While some suggested a duty to ‘teach people’ about solar, others were quite expli cit in stating that they were ‘in business’, suggesting that the profit motive was their foremost priority. In the midst of selling, it was common for sellers to ask about the appliances that the customer intended to use, since this tended to assist them in making crude approximations of the size of the solar panel that the customer might require. Thereafter, their salescraft tended to draw upon aspects of solar pro ducts that were subjective and lacking in any scien tific validity. These could be classified into a) perceptions about a product’s country of origin b) physical characteristics such as size (bigger the bet ter), c) weight (heavier the better) d) colour (black is better) and e) ‘draft’ (patterning of solar cells). As suggested in our opening scene, references to ‘Germany’ carry powerful positive connotations in the solar market. Across our findings, ‘Germany’ was widely accepted as a proxy for quality and reliability, and thus formed the cornerstone of many a salesperson’s pitch to a customer. This pitch was often bolstered b
- [2] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
lanterns. After lighting, households sought to access energy services such as charging mobile phones and powering a suite of household appliances such as radios and televisions. However, it bears mentioning that solar electricity is strongly associated with a solar panel but is seldom seen as a system that requires additional components such an inverter, battery and solar controller. As such, it is common for households to prioritize the purchase of a panel and gradually, often through trial and error, purchase the requisite components to form a com plete solar system. They were also highly unlikely to use a certified installer, usually due to a lack of aware ness or funds. Our interviews with households centered on their purchase decisions and usage practices. A striking insight from this research was that the majority house holds interviewed stated they did not consult anyone prior to making their purchase. Instead, they claimed that their decision was influenced by observations of family, friends and neighbors in the vicinity who were already using solar systems. As the Director of the Solar Trade Association expressed: ‘word of mouth and copy-cat impulses seem to play a major role in pur chase decisions” (Solar Trade Association Interview, 15 May 2019). Perhaps owing to the possibility of direct inquiry indicating lack of education or knowledge, households tended to relegate themselves to passive observation and information gathering within the community. Armed with t
- [4] Consumer Education – Lighting Global — authority
source passage
invited to test the products themselves, often in a dark room where the quality of the light can be experienced first-hand and compared against kerosene lamps and the like. Distributors and retailers are on hand to answer questions and sell their products. We also developed a series of posters, radio-spots, and TV ads that can be adapted to local audiences. This includes a comic book series called “Spotlight” that entertains young readers, while teaching them about the many uses and benefits of solar lighting and energy products. A Sampling of our Consumer Education Materials Materials include posters, comic books, radio spots, and videos. Updating our messages As awareness of solar energy products as a viable alternative takes hold in many of the areas where we are active, we adapt our messaging to end-users accordingly. As in the case of ‘Spotlight,’ the focus shifts from the singular message spreading awareness of solar lamps, and expands to promote knowledge about some of the additional energy services that these products can provide. Our market research activities ensure that we keep abreast of the knowledge consumers already possess and align the focus of our consumer awareness messaging accordingly.
- [6] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
more information, except for an exchange in Gujarati between the shopkeeper and his assistant that resulted in the response: ‘I think you are looking for more original panels, but they are too expensive. If you want to see those, you will have to walk with me to the warehouse. It’s not here’. Evidently realizing that we were not interested in what was on offer in the shop, he reached for a set of keys and left, heading away from the market with us trailing behind him. As we followed, the entrepreneur from Chitipa muttered that this kind of experience with shop owners was common and it was difficult to know what you were buying and where it actually came from. As this scenario illustrates, originality, renewable energy, and the search for ever cheaper component parts in global supply chains, sit rather incongruously, side by side. Similar scenarios to the one we recount are happening all over Africa, as the Continent experi ences a sales boom in solar products. Aided by falling manufacturing costs and permissive policy CONTACT Shanil Samarakoon [email protected] ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2021.1893428 © 2021 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group environments, off-grid solar products are now a common place commodity across the Global South. In many parts of Africa, state-led efforts to address energy poverty through a centralized grid have given way to an emphasis on off-grid market-based solutions (Munro and Bartlett 2019;
- [8] D-Lab Off-Grid Energy Group launches Solar Lighting Product — authority
source passage
information on model, manufacturer, price (in U.S. dollars), lighting output, settings and runtime, battery and solar panel specifications, features and accessories, as well as information on the warranty and certifications for some 50 products. “It is exciting to see our colleagues at D-Lab building upon CITE’s approach to develop and release such an important resource for people living in poverty,” comments Joanne Mathias, associate director of CITE. “Access to information such as this is invaluable if technology is to truly improve lives and livelihoods in the developing world.” Verploegen has a South Sudanese friend now living in the Boston-area who will be visiting his home country soon. “Phillip knows I’ve been studying solar lanterns,” Verploegen says, “and he asked me how to advise friends and family on which solar lanterns to buy. Now I can point him to this resource. His friends can click on South Sudan and find a review of products and distributors as well as detailed technical specifications in the full comparative chart.” He continues, “If the product they want is not available in South Sudan, they can use the database to look at for products available in neighboring countries such as Uganda, Kenya, and Ethiopia, and even set up businesses to import the products to their communities.” “Our goal is getting the right product into the hands of the people who need solar lighting the most and increasing the odds that investments made in these products serve the purcha
- [11] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
‘original’, many sellers stated that both the front and back labels ought to say, ‘Made in Germany’. A few sellers added that the front label would need to be ‘under the sealed glass’, suggesting that they were aware of dubious labelling efforts by manufacturers and importers. Indeed, the sheer extent to which we observed labels referring to Germany, often simply pasted on the surface, led us to question whether these labelling efforts were deliberate ploys to exploit the perceptions of Malawian buyers. This question could also be extended to labelling of the wattage of the panels, with only a single store in Mzuzu offered to test each panel with a multi-meter to prove its claimed wat tage, yet even this was offered in lieu of a warranty. In stark contrast to positive associations with Germany and South Africa (to a lesser extent), solar products from China tended to be strongly associated with being ‘fake’ or of poor equality. Some sellers tended to bypass this general negative perception of Chinese products by giving stronger emphasis to regional brand names (e.g. Ecco or Sunshine Solar) that had a stronger positive reputation in the market. This could be because these brands also arrive through trusted diaspora networks from South Africa. Some sellers stated that there were truly fake solar panels, which on their matt black surfaces had patterned stick ers in place of solar cells. However, we did not encoun ter such blatantly deceptive products during our research. In o
- [16] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
sold solar panels that claimed to be ‘Germany made’ and were often sold without the government’s mandatory minimum of a 12-month warranty on solar panels. Even MBS officials have publicly admitted that Malawi’s solar market is ‘flooded with counterfeit products’ (Malawi Nation 2019). While industry associations such as the Renewable Energy Industries Association of Malawi (REIMA) and the Solar Trade Association (STA) decry the influx of ‘fake’ products into the market due to poor regulation (Malawi Nation 2018), their influence as a lobby appears to be relatively weak (Energy Policy Expert Interview 1, 7 February 2019). 6 S. SAMARAKOON ET AL. As research findings detailed in this paper sug gest, ‘fake’ and sub-standard products are the norm in Malawi’s solar market as they are often far more accessible and affordable than affiliated, quality cer tified products. While the removal of VAT and import duties on solar products was intended to make affiliated solar products more affordable, poor regu lation means that even unaffiliated solar products are granted these tax exemptions (Energy Policy Expert Interview 1, 7 February 2019, Malawi Nation 2018). In fact, industry associations STA and REIMA have argued against excessive liberalization of the solar market as it exposes affiliated firms and con sumers to ‘an influx of sub-standard renewable energy products’ (Malawi Nation 2018). Further to this, we saw no evidence of MERA running national campaigns to educate consumers ab
- [18] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
on the back. Source: Author 8 S. SAMARAKOON ET AL. sometimes good’ (Household Interview 23, 8 February 2019). A female head of household said ‘I mainly differentiate in terms of weight. If the panel is light, I know it is from China. If it is heavier, it is original’ (Household Interview 34, 10 February 2019). We observed these trends when it came to batteries as well, with various accounts of why car batteries or ‘gas batteries’ (sealed solar batteries) were superior storage solutions. Given the dynamics most households tended to have very mixed levels of satisfaction with their solar home systems. Most were very satisfied with basic energy services such as lighting but tended to be unsatisfied when it cameto more intensive energy ser vices such as powering appliances. It is when speaking about these mixed experiences that households tended to acknowledge that their solar product was ‘fake’, ‘somewhat original’ or ‘original’. As we explained earlier, it should be noted here that the word ‘fake’ wasn’t necessarily used to suggest that the product was a forgery or did not function, but rather, that it fell well below their particular expectations. These dynamics present several ethical challenges. While the sale and purchase of sub-standard systems tend to be framed as a practice that should be discour aged, it is also evident that certified solar products are not affordable for much of the energy poor in coun tries like Malawi (Lighting Global 2020). Those that are, such a
- [21] Off-Grid Solar Market Trends Report 2019 — book
source passage
general and electronic stores, and Malawian traders that move products from these urban arteries into other parts of the country and from there into places like Chitipa, where the solar entrepreneur discussed in the introduction plies his trade (Samarakoon 2020). Complicating this flow of solar products are infor mal Malawian diaspora networks in South Africa (Ibid). This is particularly acute in Malawi’s northern region, where high unemployment continues to drive migra tion to South African urban centres (Banda, 2018). Such connections bring inflows of a wide range of electrical appliances and solar systems to power them. These systems are brought in person during annual visits or through hired transporters that negotiate border crossings and bring goods to their relatives in Malawi on their behalf (Samarakoon 2020). In Mzimba, one of north’s most prominent trading centres, we also came across evidence of second-hand solar products from South Africa being sold as brand new to unsuspecting customers. Our research suggests that these personal and affiliated responses could represent a significant inflow of solar products into northern Malawi, which has the nation’s highest concentration of solar users (NSO 2019). These diaspora-led inflows of solar pro ducts circumvent the regulatory mechanisms embedded into formal importation channels (e.g. licenses, product certification and customs checks). They can also be viewed as an exercise in agency, allowing Malawian households wh
- [23] D-Lab Off-Grid Energy Group launches Solar Lighting Product — authority
source passage
and programs working to increase access to solar energy products where they are most needed,” Verploegen says. “Our job was to figure out what was missing.” Verploegen was intrigued by the work coming out of MIT’s Comprehensive Initiative on Technology Evaluation (CITE). CITE has developed and piloted a methodology for evaluating products intended for the developing world focusing on the dimensions of suitability, scalability, and sustainability. Their first study of solar lanterns available in Uganda, published in early 2015, included a comparative chart of solar lanterns available in Uganda. “CITE is pioneering a rigorous methodology for evaluation,” comments Verploegen. “What D-Lab’s Off-Grid Energy wanted to bring to the table was the rapid dissemination of comparable product specifications linked to geographically organized distributor contact information around the world.” Verploegen didn’t have to start from scratch. Inspired by CITE’s Uganda Solar Lantern study, Verploegen researched the availability of solar lighting product information that was global in scale. He found Lighting Global, the World Bank Group platform, which has been providing basic information on solar lighting products that meet minimum quality standards since 2009 and continuously updates their database. In developing this resource, D-Lab’s Off-Grid Energy Group working from Lighting Global’s database (in fact, they will include only products that have passed Lighting Global’s quality assurance sta
across twenty-eight stores in Northern Malawi – none of whom had formal techni cal training in relation to selling or installing solar systems. There was broad acknowledgement among these sellers that there was a lack of knowledge among consumers about solar products. However, there were varied stances on the level of responsibil ity they bore as sellers. While some suggested a duty to ‘teach people’ about solar, others were quite expli cit in stating that they were ‘in business’, suggesting that the profit motive was their foremost priority. In the midst of selling, it was common for sellers to ask about the appliances that the customer intended to use, since this tended to assist them in making crude approximations of the size of the solar panel that the customer might require. Thereafter, their salescraft tended to draw upon aspects of solar pro ducts that were subjective and lacking in any scien tific validity. These could be classified into a) perceptions about a product’s country of origin b) physical characteristics such as size (bigger the bet ter), c) weight (heavier the better) d) colour (black is better) and e) ‘draft’ (patterning of solar cells). As suggested in our opening scene, references to ‘Germany’ carry powerful positive connotations in the solar market. Across our findings, ‘Germany’ was widely accepted as a proxy for quality and reliability, and thus formed the cornerstone of many a salesperson’s pitch to a customer. This pitch was often bolstered b
lanterns. After lighting, households sought to access energy services such as charging mobile phones and powering a suite of household appliances such as radios and televisions. However, it bears mentioning that solar electricity is strongly associated with a solar panel but is seldom seen as a system that requires additional components such an inverter, battery and solar controller. As such, it is common for households to prioritize the purchase of a panel and gradually, often through trial and error, purchase the requisite components to form a com plete solar system. They were also highly unlikely to use a certified installer, usually due to a lack of aware ness or funds. Our interviews with households centered on their purchase decisions and usage practices. A striking insight from this research was that the majority house holds interviewed stated they did not consult anyone prior to making their purchase. Instead, they claimed that their decision was influenced by observations of family, friends and neighbors in the vicinity who were already using solar systems. As the Director of the Solar Trade Association expressed: ‘word of mouth and copy-cat impulses seem to play a major role in pur chase decisions” (Solar Trade Association Interview, 15 May 2019). Perhaps owing to the possibility of direct inquiry indicating lack of education or knowledge, households tended to relegate themselves to passive observation and information gathering within the community. Armed with t
invited to test the products themselves, often in a dark room where the quality of the light can be experienced first-hand and compared against kerosene lamps and the like. Distributors and retailers are on hand to answer questions and sell their products. We also developed a series of posters, radio-spots, and TV ads that can be adapted to local audiences. This includes a comic book series called “Spotlight” that entertains young readers, while teaching them about the many uses and benefits of solar lighting and energy products. A Sampling of our Consumer Education Materials Materials include posters, comic books, radio spots, and videos. Updating our messages As awareness of solar energy products as a viable alternative takes hold in many of the areas where we are active, we adapt our messaging to end-users accordingly. As in the case of ‘Spotlight,’ the focus shifts from the singular message spreading awareness of solar lamps, and expands to promote knowledge about some of the additional energy services that these products can provide. Our market research activities ensure that we keep abreast of the knowledge consumers already possess and align the focus of our consumer awareness messaging accordingly.
more information, except for an exchange in Gujarati between the shopkeeper and his assistant that resulted in the response: ‘I think you are looking for more original panels, but they are too expensive. If you want to see those, you will have to walk with me to the warehouse. It’s not here’. Evidently realizing that we were not interested in what was on offer in the shop, he reached for a set of keys and left, heading away from the market with us trailing behind him. As we followed, the entrepreneur from Chitipa muttered that this kind of experience with shop owners was common and it was difficult to know what you were buying and where it actually came from. As this scenario illustrates, originality, renewable energy, and the search for ever cheaper component parts in global supply chains, sit rather incongruously, side by side. Similar scenarios to the one we recount are happening all over Africa, as the Continent experi ences a sales boom in solar products. Aided by falling manufacturing costs and permissive policy CONTACT Shanil Samarakoon [email protected] ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2021.1893428 © 2021 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group environments, off-grid solar products are now a common place commodity across the Global South. In many parts of Africa, state-led efforts to address energy poverty through a centralized grid have given way to an emphasis on off-grid market-based solutions (Munro and Bartlett 2019;
information on model, manufacturer, price (in U.S. dollars), lighting output, settings and runtime, battery and solar panel specifications, features and accessories, as well as information on the warranty and certifications for some 50 products. “It is exciting to see our colleagues at D-Lab building upon CITE’s approach to develop and release such an important resource for people living in poverty,” comments Joanne Mathias, associate director of CITE. “Access to information such as this is invaluable if technology is to truly improve lives and livelihoods in the developing world.” Verploegen has a South Sudanese friend now living in the Boston-area who will be visiting his home country soon. “Phillip knows I’ve been studying solar lanterns,” Verploegen says, “and he asked me how to advise friends and family on which solar lanterns to buy. Now I can point him to this resource. His friends can click on South Sudan and find a review of products and distributors as well as detailed technical specifications in the full comparative chart.” He continues, “If the product they want is not available in South Sudan, they can use the database to look at for products available in neighboring countries such as Uganda, Kenya, and Ethiopia, and even set up businesses to import the products to their communities.” “Our goal is getting the right product into the hands of the people who need solar lighting the most and increasing the odds that investments made in these products serve the purcha
‘original’, many sellers stated that both the front and back labels ought to say, ‘Made in Germany’. A few sellers added that the front label would need to be ‘under the sealed glass’, suggesting that they were aware of dubious labelling efforts by manufacturers and importers. Indeed, the sheer extent to which we observed labels referring to Germany, often simply pasted on the surface, led us to question whether these labelling efforts were deliberate ploys to exploit the perceptions of Malawian buyers. This question could also be extended to labelling of the wattage of the panels, with only a single store in Mzuzu offered to test each panel with a multi-meter to prove its claimed wat tage, yet even this was offered in lieu of a warranty. In stark contrast to positive associations with Germany and South Africa (to a lesser extent), solar products from China tended to be strongly associated with being ‘fake’ or of poor equality. Some sellers tended to bypass this general negative perception of Chinese products by giving stronger emphasis to regional brand names (e.g. Ecco or Sunshine Solar) that had a stronger positive reputation in the market. This could be because these brands also arrive through trusted diaspora networks from South Africa. Some sellers stated that there were truly fake solar panels, which on their matt black surfaces had patterned stick ers in place of solar cells. However, we did not encoun ter such blatantly deceptive products during our research. In o
sold solar panels that claimed to be ‘Germany made’ and were often sold without the government’s mandatory minimum of a 12-month warranty on solar panels. Even MBS officials have publicly admitted that Malawi’s solar market is ‘flooded with counterfeit products’ (Malawi Nation 2019). While industry associations such as the Renewable Energy Industries Association of Malawi (REIMA) and the Solar Trade Association (STA) decry the influx of ‘fake’ products into the market due to poor regulation (Malawi Nation 2018), their influence as a lobby appears to be relatively weak (Energy Policy Expert Interview 1, 7 February 2019). 6 S. SAMARAKOON ET AL. As research findings detailed in this paper sug gest, ‘fake’ and sub-standard products are the norm in Malawi’s solar market as they are often far more accessible and affordable than affiliated, quality cer tified products. While the removal of VAT and import duties on solar products was intended to make affiliated solar products more affordable, poor regu lation means that even unaffiliated solar products are granted these tax exemptions (Energy Policy Expert Interview 1, 7 February 2019, Malawi Nation 2018). In fact, industry associations STA and REIMA have argued against excessive liberalization of the solar market as it exposes affiliated firms and con sumers to ‘an influx of sub-standard renewable energy products’ (Malawi Nation 2018). Further to this, we saw no evidence of MERA running national campaigns to educate consumers ab
on the back. Source: Author 8 S. SAMARAKOON ET AL. sometimes good’ (Household Interview 23, 8 February 2019). A female head of household said ‘I mainly differentiate in terms of weight. If the panel is light, I know it is from China. If it is heavier, it is original’ (Household Interview 34, 10 February 2019). We observed these trends when it came to batteries as well, with various accounts of why car batteries or ‘gas batteries’ (sealed solar batteries) were superior storage solutions. Given the dynamics most households tended to have very mixed levels of satisfaction with their solar home systems. Most were very satisfied with basic energy services such as lighting but tended to be unsatisfied when it cameto more intensive energy ser vices such as powering appliances. It is when speaking about these mixed experiences that households tended to acknowledge that their solar product was ‘fake’, ‘somewhat original’ or ‘original’. As we explained earlier, it should be noted here that the word ‘fake’ wasn’t necessarily used to suggest that the product was a forgery or did not function, but rather, that it fell well below their particular expectations. These dynamics present several ethical challenges. While the sale and purchase of sub-standard systems tend to be framed as a practice that should be discour aged, it is also evident that certified solar products are not affordable for much of the energy poor in coun tries like Malawi (Lighting Global 2020). Those that are, such a
general and electronic stores, and Malawian traders that move products from these urban arteries into other parts of the country and from there into places like Chitipa, where the solar entrepreneur discussed in the introduction plies his trade (Samarakoon 2020). Complicating this flow of solar products are infor mal Malawian diaspora networks in South Africa (Ibid). This is particularly acute in Malawi’s northern region, where high unemployment continues to drive migra tion to South African urban centres (Banda, 2018). Such connections bring inflows of a wide range of electrical appliances and solar systems to power them. These systems are brought in person during annual visits or through hired transporters that negotiate border crossings and bring goods to their relatives in Malawi on their behalf (Samarakoon 2020). In Mzimba, one of north’s most prominent trading centres, we also came across evidence of second-hand solar products from South Africa being sold as brand new to unsuspecting customers. Our research suggests that these personal and affiliated responses could represent a significant inflow of solar products into northern Malawi, which has the nation’s highest concentration of solar users (NSO 2019). These diaspora-led inflows of solar pro ducts circumvent the regulatory mechanisms embedded into formal importation channels (e.g. licenses, product certification and customs checks). They can also be viewed as an exercise in agency, allowing Malawian households wh
and programs working to increase access to solar energy products where they are most needed,” Verploegen says. “Our job was to figure out what was missing.” Verploegen was intrigued by the work coming out of MIT’s Comprehensive Initiative on Technology Evaluation (CITE). CITE has developed and piloted a methodology for evaluating products intended for the developing world focusing on the dimensions of suitability, scalability, and sustainability. Their first study of solar lanterns available in Uganda, published in early 2015, included a comparative chart of solar lanterns available in Uganda. “CITE is pioneering a rigorous methodology for evaluation,” comments Verploegen. “What D-Lab’s Off-Grid Energy wanted to bring to the table was the rapid dissemination of comparable product specifications linked to geographically organized distributor contact information around the world.” Verploegen didn’t have to start from scratch. Inspired by CITE’s Uganda Solar Lantern study, Verploegen researched the availability of solar lighting product information that was global in scale. He found Lighting Global, the World Bank Group platform, which has been providing basic information on solar lighting products that meet minimum quality standards since 2009 and continuously updates their database. In developing this resource, D-Lab’s Off-Grid Energy Group working from Lighting Global’s database (in fact, they will include only products that have passed Lighting Global’s quality assurance sta